Compass Cay has a naturally-protected harbor that been outfitted with a beach lodge and a marina. The island also has docile nurse sharks which you can swim with if you are brave. Forge memories of a lifetime by doing something that makes the hairs on your neck rise. Jump out of your comfort zone and into the shark-infested waters around Compass Cay Marina. Do so with confidence and comfort knowing thousands of visitors before you have done it and survived to tell a great story from a great Bahamas vacation. Believe it or not, Compass Cay Bahamas used to be known for another thing before the Bahamas sharks arrived; its beautiful beaches! This is a great spot for lunch (burgers, etc.) but they are not open for dinner.